I buy a good amount of makeup on a regular basis, so I thought I'd compare some products I've bought fairly recently. It is... Makeup Battle!
Round One: Maybelline Ultra Liner vs. Dolly Wink eyeliner
I have been wearing liquid eyeliner everyday for... years! I've tried a ton of different brands and continue my quest for the best. So far I do have a favorite but I thought I'd give Dolly Wink a chance.
NO CONTEST! Maybelline Ultra Liner is better in almost every way! First, it's waterproof. Second, it's thick and dark. Third, it's practically un-smudge-able. Forth, it's only about $10!
While Dolly Wink may be sacred to some, I was extremely disappointed! First, it's a felt-tip applicator, which
can be cool. I've tried several brands (Japanese and others) of eyeliner that were a felt tip applicator, they are only good if the actual product is thick and high pigment. Unfortunately, Dolly Wink is thin and comes out looking gray. Second, it smudges extremely easily and is not waterproof. Third, the pen is so fine, it's not really practical as an eyeliner. I had to go over my eyes several times to get a thick enough line. When would you ever need an eyeliner that fine? Maybe if you were drawing a fake tattoo or something. Forth, it's fairly expensive. It was $18 at Mitsuwa Marketplace (local supermarket). You can get Lorac for that much.
Round Two: Maybelline Colossal Volume vs. Loreal Double Extend
I bought both of these on the recommendation of YouTube beauty experts! I can't remember where I heard about Colossal Volume, but I know I heard about Double Extend from
Kandee Johnson, the makeup artist.
Double Extend makes your lashes look thick, long and gorgeous! I really love this one, but... I am so impatient and I hate having to put on two layers (white primer + black color)!!
Colossal Volume doesn't look quite as good, but it works if you are in a hurry or are just putting on mascara before using false lashes. I like that it's quick and
easy!
Round Three: BWC Eye Makeup Remover vs. Earth Science Eye Makeup Remover
So, I am kind of a hippie when it comes to some things... Aside from drugstore cosmetics, I try to only use organic, "cruelty-free" products. Both of these are available at Whole Foods (or Rainbow Grocery, if you live in SF!).

BWC wins! It's mainly because of consistency. BWC Eye Makeup Remover is liquid and leaves no residue. So it's ideal for cleaning up mistakes you might have made while applying your makeup. Earth Science is thick and gloopy, like sludge and it leaves a weird residue. It's only good for removing makeup at night but even then I have to rinse of the slimy residue after I use it.
Some people like to use olive oil to remove eye makeup. I've tried it but it's too oily (obviously, it's oily) for my liking. Maybe I'm sensitive to texture!
I hope you enjoyed the Makeup Battle. (Do you like my aluminum foil background? I thought it made the pics look comicbook-esque!) Hopefully it was useful in your makeup shopping.